top of page
ashphalt striping 1_edited.jpg
Asphalt

News and Insights

Things to Consider Before Sealing Driveways

Writer: Master Markings
Master Markings
Mar 28, 2024
9 min read

Updated: Sep 16

Sealing driveway surfaces correctly is one of the smartest investments you can make in your asphalt's long-term health, yet many homeowners still get it wrong. In this guide, we'll walk through everything you need to know — from choosing between coal tar, asphalt emulsion, acrylic, and urethane sealers to knowing exactly when your driveway is ready for its first coat. Whether you're weighing sealing driveway options for a brand-new installation or resealing pavement that's been in place for a decade, you'll find clear, practical answers here.

Unlike many surface-level articles on this topic, we go beyond simply naming sealer types. Instead, we explain why each product performs differently, how weather and traffic affect the outcome, and what a professional actually does during application. As a result, by the end of this guide, you shouldn't need to search anywhere else for answers about protecting your pavement.

Why Driveway Sealing Matters for Long-Term Durability

First, it's worth understanding what sealing actually does. A sealcoat is a thin protective layer applied over cured asphalt pavement that shields it from sun, moisture, and chemical exposure. In particular, it slows oxidation, keeps water from seeping into the base layer, and reduces the chance of oil and gas stains soaking in permanently.

However, sealing is not a magic fix. It will not repair structural problems, and it won't stop every type of crack from forming. Above all, it's a maintenance step that extends the life of pavement that was properly installed in the first place. Therefore, understanding both the benefits and the limitations of sealing your driveway helps you set realistic expectations before you spend a dime.

Sealing Driveway 101: What Every Homeowner Should Know

As the team at Angie's List explains in their guide to sealing your driveway, sealcoating improves appearance and helps reduce the likelihood of cracks — but it isn't strictly required for every driveway. Cracks develop for several reasons, and weather is only one of them.

Insufficient curing time and heavy vehicle traffic are two of the most common culprits. Sealing primarily protects against weather-related cracking, so even a freshly sealed driveway can still crack if it was sealed too early or if delivery trucks and heavy equipment repeatedly drive across it before it's fully cured.

Other causes include improper soil compaction, expanding soils, and tree roots pushing up from underneath. To minimize this risk, make sure your asphalt is poured over at least five inches of properly compacted gravel base. Similarly, keep trees a safe distance from the driveway so that, as roots mature, they don't compromise the pavement's structural integrity. For a deeper breakdown of what causes pavement damage, see our guide on the common causes of driveway cracks and how to prevent them.

As asphalt ages, ultraviolet rays fade the surface and repeated heating and cooling cycles cause it to expand and contract. Consequently, this cycle eventually leads to cracking whether the driveway is sealed or not. Sealing slows this process considerably, but it does not stop it forever — which is exactly why periodic resealing, not a single one-time application, is the real key to long-term protection.

The Different Types of Asphalt Sealers Compared

Choosing the right product is the single biggest decision you'll make when sealing driveway pavement. Each sealer type has a distinct chemical makeup, and each behaves differently depending on climate, traffic load, and budget. Below, we break down the five most common options in detail.

Coal Tar Sealers

Coal tar sealer has long been the industry standard because it's inexpensive and highly resistant to oil, gasoline, and de-icing salts. In addition, it dries to a rich black finish that many homeowners prefer aesthetically.

  • Pros: Excellent chemical resistance, low cost, deep black finish, strong UV resistance.

  • Cons: Contains coal tar compounds classified as polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) — a chemical group linked to environmental runoff concerns. As a result, several states and municipalities restrict or outright ban its use. It's also more brittle in cold climates and needs constant agitation during application.

Asphalt Emulsion (Asphalt-Based) Sealers

Asphalt emulsion sealers use asphalt cement mixed with water and emulsifying agents rather than coal tar. Consequently, they're viewed as a more environmentally friendly middle-ground option.

  • Pros: Fewer regulatory restrictions, lower odor, easier for DIY application, moderate cost.

  • Cons: Less resistant to oil and gas stains than coal tar, softens more in extreme heat, and typically needs reapplication sooner.

Acrylic Sealers

Acrylic sealers are polymer-based and are increasingly popular where coal tar is restricted. In particular, they're prized for flexibility and superior color retention.

  • Pros: Excellent UV stability, low VOC formulations available, flexible finish that resists cracking, faster drying time.

  • Cons: Higher upfront cost, weaker resistance to oil and fuel stains compared with coal tar, and may require more frequent coats in high-traffic driveways.

Oil-Based (Petroleum) Sealers

Oil-based sealers are less common today but still appear in some regional markets. They provide decent flexibility in cold weather; however, they cure slowly, carry a stronger odor, and have largely been replaced by acrylic and emulsion alternatives.

Urethane and Polymer-Modified Sealers

These premium formulas blend traditional sealer bases with polymer additives for enhanced durability. Specifically, they resist cracking, oxidation, and chemical exposure better than any standard product, which is why they're often used on commercial lots and driveways with heavy vehicle traffic. The tradeoff is a noticeably higher price tag.

How to Choose the Right Sealer for Your Climate and Driveway

There's no single "best" sealer for every situation. Instead, the right choice depends on your climate, traffic volume, and local regulations.

  • Hot, sunny climates: Acrylic sealers hold up best against UV fading and heat softening.

  • Cold climates with freeze-thaw cycles: Flexible urethane or acrylic blends resist cracking better than rigid coal tar.

  • Heavy vehicle or commercial traffic: Urethane or polymer-modified sealers offer the strongest wear resistance.

  • Tight budgets: Asphalt emulsion sealers offer solid protection at a lower cost.

  • Areas with coal tar restrictions: Check local ordinances first, since many counties now require asphalt-based or acrylic alternatives.

For additional product comparisons and application advice, take a look at our expert tips for sealing asphalt driveways, which covers real-world application scenarios in more depth.

When Should You Seal a New Asphalt Driveway?

Timing matters just as much as the product itself. New asphalt needs time to cure fully before it can handle a sealcoat. Generally speaking, most contractors recommend waiting 30 to 90 days after installation, depending on temperature and sun exposure. Sealing too early traps oils and solvents that haven't fully evaporated, which weakens the bond and can cause premature peeling.

Meanwhile, waiting too long isn't ideal either, since unprotected asphalt begins oxidizing and fading almost immediately. As a result, the sweet spot is that 30-to-90-day curing window — no earlier, no later.

How Often Should You Reseal Your Driveway?

Most driveways benefit from resealing every two to three years, though this varies based on sealer type, climate severity, and how much traffic the surface handles daily. Driveways in harsh winter climates or under constant sun exposure typically need attention closer to the two-year mark, while lightly used driveways in mild climates can sometimes stretch to four years between applications.

In contrast to a one-and-done mindset, think of sealing your driveway as an ongoing maintenance routine — similar to repainting a fence or replacing roof shingles. Consistent reapplication is what actually maximizes your pavement's lifespan.

Preparing Your Driveway Before Sealing

Before any sealer touches the surface, existing cracks and deficiencies must be corrected. Otherwise, sealing over damage is like putting lipstick on a pig — the underlying problems keep growing and eventually undermine the entire purpose of sealing in the first place.

Proper preparation typically includes the following:

  • Sweeping and power-washing the surface to remove dirt, debris, and loose material.

  • Degreasing any oil or fuel stains so the sealer bonds evenly.

  • Filling cracks and potholes with an appropriate patching compound before the sealcoat goes down. Learn more about our professional crack filling services if your driveway already shows visible damage.

  • Allowing patched areas to cure fully before applying sealer on top.

DIY Driveway Sealing vs. Hiring a Professional

While you can technically seal your driveway yourself, hiring a professional is generally the smarter route. Above all, professionals guarantee even, thorough coverage — something that's surprisingly difficult to achieve by hand with a squeegee.

If you do hire a contractor, walk through every detail with them beforehand. For example, ask whether they're using a water-based, acrylic, or urethane sealer, since different products respond differently depending on your local climate. Furthermore, confirm that any existing cracks or surface deficiencies will be corrected prior to sealing, not glossed over.

On the other hand, DIY sealing can save money on smaller driveways if you're comfortable with the physical labor and have realistic expectations about coverage quality. Just be sure to check the weather forecast, since most sealers require dry conditions and moderate temperatures for at least 24 to 48 hours after application.

How Professionals Seal a Driveway: Step-by-Step Process

Curious what actually happens on sealing day? Here's the process most professional crews follow from start to finish:

  1. Clean the surface thoroughly: Crews sweep away debris and use a power washer or blower to remove dirt, sand, and loose asphalt particles before any product is applied.

  2. Repair cracks and potholes: Any existing damage is filled with a rubberized crack filler or patching compound and given time to cure completely before sealing begins.

  3. Mask edges and adjacent surfaces: Grass, concrete, and garage entrances are protected with tape or plastic sheeting to keep the sealer contained to the driveway.

  4. Apply the first coat: A thin, even layer of sealer is spread using a squeegee or sprayer, working in small sections to avoid pooling or streaking.

  5. Allow the first coat to cure: Depending on temperature and humidity, this typically takes several hours before a second coat can safely be applied.

  6. Apply a second coat: A follow-up layer ensures complete, uniform coverage and significantly extends the durability of the finished surface.

  7. Cure before reopening to traffic: Most sealers need 24 to 48 hours before foot traffic and up to 72 hours before vehicles can safely drive on the surface.

What Does Sealing a Driveway Cost?

Cost depends heavily on driveway size, sealer type, and how much prep work — like crack repair — is needed beforehand. Generally, acrylic and urethane products cost more per square foot than asphalt emulsion, but they often pay for themselves through longer intervals between applications.

Because pricing varies significantly by region, we've put together a complete cost and timing guide specific to Virginia driveways, covering everything from square-footage pricing to seasonal scheduling considerations. For a deeper walkthrough, see our News and Insights.

Signs Your Driveway Needs Sealing

Not sure if it's time yet? Look for these telltale signs:

  • The surface has faded from deep black to dull gray.

  • Water no longer beads on the surface after rainfall.

  • The pavement feels dry, brittle, or slightly crumbly underfoot.

  • Small hairline cracks are beginning to appear.

  • It's been two or more years since the last sealcoat.

Frequently Asked Questions About Sealing Driveway Surfaces

How long does it take for driveway sealer to dry?

Most sealers are dry to the touch within 4 to 8 hours, but full curing before vehicle traffic typically takes 24 to 72 hours depending on the product and weather conditions.

Can I seal my driveway myself, or should I hire a professional?

You can seal a driveway yourself with the right tools, but professionals typically achieve more even coverage and know how to properly prep and repair the surface first, which improves long-term results. For a deeper walkthrough, see our News and Insights.

How soon after paving can I seal a new asphalt driveway?

Wait at least 30 to 90 days after installation so the asphalt fully cures. Sealing too early traps solvents underneath and weakens the bond.

How often should I reseal my driveway?

Most homeowners should reseal every two to three years, though heavy traffic or harsh climates may require more frequent applications.

Is coal tar sealer safe to use?

Coal tar sealer contains PAH compounds that raise environmental runoff concerns, and many states and counties now restrict or ban its residential use. Asphalt emulsion or acrylic alternatives are considered safer choices where regulations apply.

What is the best temperature for sealing driveway surfaces?

Ideal conditions for sealing driveway pavement are between 50°F and 85°F with no rain expected for at least 24 hours, since cold or wet conditions prevent proper curing.

Final Thoughts on Sealing Your Driveway the Right Way

In summary, sealing driveway surfaces protects against sun damage, moisture, and chemical stains — but it only works when paired with proper prep, the right sealer for your climate, and a realistic reapplication schedule. Coal tar, asphalt emulsion, acrylic, and urethane sealers each offer distinct tradeoffs, so choose based on your traffic level, budget, and local regulations rather than price alone.

Finally, remember that cracks and deficiencies must always be repaired before sealing, since skipping this step undermines the entire process. We invite you to contact us for more information about sealing driveways and the full range of services we offer. We'll be happy to answer your questions and walk through every detail with you.

 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Master Markings Striping Customer Service Qualities

Master Markings' striping customer service comes down to clear communication, a family-run team with experience since 1997, free quotes, a cleaning-first approach to surface prep, and a follow-up call

 
 
ashphalt striping 1_edited.jpg
Asphalt

Protect Your Asphalt: Contact Master Markings

Our team at Master Markings is dedicated to providing top-quality asphalt seal coating and striping services.  Submit an online inquiry today and we will get back to you as soon as possible.
bottom of page